Administering Idaho's Workers' Compensation Law

Disputed Claims

If an injured worker (claimant) has a disagreement with the insurer/employer that cannot be resolved informally, the claimant can use the formal judicial process. The Commission's judicial process is governed by the Judicial Rules of Practice and Procedure under the Idaho Workers' Compensation Law. Due to the complexity of the judicial process, it is recommended that you contact an attorney.

There are several steps and important timelines for cases that are decided by the Commission. We have created a flow chart showing the steps in a typical claim.

The basic steps in the formal judicial process are:

Initiating the process (top)

The judicial process is started by filing a complaint. The original complaint is filed with the Commission and a copy must be sent to the employer or insurance company. All information on the complaint form must be included.

Preparing the case (top)

After filing the complaint, the case must be prepared and presented to the Hearing Officer. Some typical steps are listed below but this is not a complete list. If you have questions, you may want to consult an attorney.

  • Gather all known medical records
  • Organize the records
  • Read and understand the records
  • Determine what your doctor will say1
  • Exchange interrogatories2
  • Gather other evidence, documents, and information necessary to prove your claim

1 Ask your doctor about his/her experience with workers' compensation. A doctor with experience in workers' compensation may be able to assist you in documenting whether you qualify for benefits.

2 Interrogatories are written questions that one person asks the other and the other must answer.

Scheduling the hearing (top)

To obtain a decision from the Hearing Officer, a hearing must be held on your case. To arrange for a hearing, file a request for calendaring1 with the Commission. The hearing will be held before a hearing officer. The other parties will be present. Evidence and testimony are presented. Examination and cross-examination will be allowed. The proceedings will be recorded by a court recorder and a transcript is commonly prepared.

Post-hearing depositions and briefs may be required. When the case is finally presented to the Hearing Officer, a decision is typically issued within three months.

Some costs may be incurred in preparing for and attending a hearing. If you have questions for concerns about costs and expenses you may want to seek legal counsel.

1 A request for calendaring is a letter to the Commission to request a hearing date. See the Judicial Rules of Practice and Procedure under the Idaho Workers' Compensation Laws for more information.

Appealing the decision (top)

If you disagree with the hearing decision you can ask the Commission for a reconsideration. You have twenty days to file a motion for reconsideration.

The Commission will issue a ruling on the motion for reconsideration. If the claimant is still dissatisfied with the outcome, an appeal may be filed with the Idaho Supreme Court. The Idaho Supreme Court has its own rules and procedures for appeals.

Or, if you do not wish to file a reconsideration, you may file an appeal with the Idaho Supreme Court within 42 days of the hearing decision. The Idaho Supreme Court has its own rules and procedures for appeals.